On the Parable of the Good Samaritan in the Age of Artificial Intelligence
As I revisit the conclusion of my 2010 doctoral dissertation on Charles Taylor, originally written under the title Charles Taylor and Modern Identity, I realize that many of the problems that structured that work now reappear in the contemporary debate on artificial intelligence.
Artificial intelligence is not only a new technology. Nor is it merely an ambivalent tool, capable of emancipatory or destructive uses depending on the political conditions in which it is embedded. It is also a new figure within a long history through which life, speech, the body, and suffering are translated into administrable categories. What appeared in Taylor as the problem of modern identity, and in the work of the theologian Ivan Illich as the institutional corruption of Christianity, reappears today in the form of an algorithmic bureaucracy capable of reorganizing the very field in which something can appear as visible, useful, communicable, governable, or recognizable.
The question that serves as the guiding thread is not new. It appears in the Gospel of Luke, when a lawyer asks Jesus: “And who is my neighbor?” The question seeks to establish a kind of delimitation or boundary. The lawyer wants to know how far moral obligation extends. He wants to know who belongs within the circle of responsibility and who remains outside it. Jesus responds with the parable of the Good Samaritan: a man falls wounded on the road. A priest and a Levite pass by him, but they continue their way, indifferent to the man’s suffering. A Samaritan, however, stops, approaches him, bandages his wounds, takes him to an inn, and cares for him.
Continue reading